Wild on Books - Book Reviews


 

   

Eternal Love

Maggie Shayne

   
                 

      

  

 

  

    

      

  

 

  

    

  

    

 

 

Publisher:
Berkley Trade

Release Date:
November 6, 2007

Genres:
Paranormal Romance
Reincarnation
Historical Romance

ISBN:
Print
9780425217399

Bookmark Rating:
3 1/2 Bookmarks!

Reviewed by
Jennifer Ray

Review Posted:
May 2008

 

~ETERNITY

Raven St. James and her mother are accused of witchcraft one fateful evening, and summarily executed in the center of their village.  One man stood alone against their accusers, trying to save them, but was doomed to failure in the face of so many.

Duncan Wallace never forgot his failure, nor could he forget the beauty that touched his heart so in the space of a mere moment.  Her vision haunts him as if she were still alive and breathing even today.

But Raven is alive and breathing, and Immortal High Witch who is now immersed in the struggle for her very life as she flees from the mortals who would kill her out of fear and the Dark Ones who would take her very heart in order to prolong their own evil lives.  Her flight lands her in America, where she and Duncan finally meet again and consummate their love all to briefly before he is killed trying to save her from a mob once again.

Having sacrificed himself to save another witch, Duncan will be reborn as an Immortal High Witch one day.  If it takes an eternity, Raven will wait for him.

Having read some of Maggie Shayne’s previous work, I expected to love this book.  It had everything I wanted – an author whose work I admired, a plot that intrigued me, and characters who piqued my interest.

What unnerved me in the story was the fact that it moves back and forth between first person point of view and third person point of view.  I am not a reader who minds either one, and I rarely notice which voice a story is written in, but having both in the same book was extremely distracting for me, and made it difficult to really immerse myself in the book, no matter how interesting the plot was.

Other than that, the plot stood up to my expectations, as did the character building.  Were it not for the issue I had with the book constantly switching between first person and third person, I imagine I would have been able to enjoy ETERNITY much more than I did.

All that aside, I am glad I read the book, as it provided a basis for the later stories in this saga, which I was able to enjoy more from knowing the history behind all of the characters. 

~INFINITY

After the defeat of the Dark One who took the life of Arianna’s lover centuries ago, she discovers the many secrets in his journals – among them the fact that an Immortal High Witch whose heart has been taken can be revived by replacing their heart.

This knowledge brings Arianna hope she never dreamed of, and she sets off on a journey to Nicodimus’ resting place, to attempt just such a resuscitation herself.

It works.  But Nicodimus has few memories upon waking, and those he has brand her a betrayer to him.

As with the first book in this collection, I fully anticipated this being a tale I would adore.  Also like ETERNITY, I enjoyed the plot and characters in INFINITY immensely.

While it was not quite as prevalent as in the previous story, INFINITY also switched between first person and third person point of view, which disrupted the flow of the story and made it impossible for me to lose myself in it.  I will say that there was less of this in INFINITY than there was in ETERNITY, however.

As with the preceding tale, I wouldn’t recommend missing this story if you are planning to read those that follow INFINITY in this saga. 

 

NoteThis review was originally written by Jennifer Ray for another review site.  It is being reposted at Wild on Books.

 

Buy it in Print
at Amazon:

 

      

  

 

  

    

      

  

 

  

    

  

    

 

HOME | REVIEWS | INTERVIEWS | OUR STORES | EVENTS | CONTESTS  | LINKS | ABOUT US | CONTACT US | SITE SEARCH | SITE MAP

Copyright © 2008 Wild on Books.  All rights reserved.